Showing posts with label Business of Medicine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Business of Medicine. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

A death spiral in evolution

It is truly fascinating to witness a corporate death spiral firsthand.  Here's how one just unfolded in my presence.

  • Company A, a software as a service (SAS) solution lands big client, Company B, an EMR company.
  • The arrangement flourishes.
In business--and life--the only constant is change.  In this case change produced:
  • Increase in demand for company B's SAS solution
  • Company A needs to invest in infrastructure to support Company B's plans.
Credit Crunch or bad Management?
  • Company A unable or unwilling to accomodate Company B's plans
  • Company B finds SAS vendor that will
The death spiral begins.
  • Company B signs with Company C, the new SAS provider
  • Company A makes lay offs of technical employees
  • Service declines at Company A
  • Company B gets tons of complaints
  • Company B pulls remaining clients from Company A
  • Company A has problems.
Wow!

Could this have been avoided by Company A.  In this economy, who knows?  Probably not.  I wish them luck.

Dr Schoor

Sunday, October 04, 2009

Are meetings worthwhile?

As reimbursements continue to decline for many of us and we are forced to remain in the office longer and longer to make up the lost income, our attendance in meetings has taken a back seat in importance. This is a shame and you may wish to re-think this cost-cutting strategy.

Meetings are very, very important. You'd be better off cutting out some othe expense.

Meetings allow attendees to re-charge their batteries and return to the office energized and more productive than ever. Only through meeting with colleagues face to face can doctors forge new relationships that are important for networking and business development. While we may be able to learn new techniques and advances in our field through online CME courses, we learn best in person where the dialogue is 2 way and we have access to non-verbal communication.

Meetings are not cheap. Flights, hotel, registration, and time away add up to thoudands of dollars. However, if you choose your meeting wisely, increased revenue will offet the costs many times over. All it takes is learning one new CPT code or one new modifier or a new profitable procedure and you will payed back in triplicate, at least.

I just think this is not an option for cost cutting.

Friday, September 11, 2009

Craziness or Opportunity

I needed medical records from a patient's recent hospital admission for continuity of care purposes. I recieved the records today but they were sent not by the hospital itself, which is 3 miles from my office, but from a 3rd party operation located in North Carolina, approximately 800 miles away.

IOD, Inc.

Crazy, right? Why can't the hospital just send me the records when I request them?

Well the answer is that due to the complexity of federal privacy laws, the hospital has decided to outsource the management of the release of health information. The hospital pays this company and the company assumes the liability associated with a violation of HIPAA. Other than slight inconvenience to me, patient privacy is assured, the law is followed to the letter, and some entreprenurial person makes money. Win, win, win.

What can this teach us? For one thing, you can view regulatory change as a pain in the rear or as an opportunity for improvement or even new business.

Since the business and regulatory world are always changing, I recommend that you embrace the change and and use to your advantage.

Thursday, September 10, 2009

Fighting Murphy: what are your checks and balances?


People can slip through the cracks easily.
  • Patients can walk out of the office with their encounter forms or charge slips.

  • The office staff can forget to give them a follow-up appointment.

  • Patients can call to cancel an appointment, intend to re-schedule, then forget to do so.

  • Patients can no-show.

  • Staff can forget to put the patient on the recall list.

  • Staff can put the wrong patient on the recall list.
  • The doctor can get forget to write the order for the test or the follow-up.
  • The doctor can forget to click on the order or the request for follow-up.
  • Handwriting can be illegible.
  • The computer can crash.
  • Murphy can and will show up.

In a doctor's office, this can be dangerous.

The only way to prevent Murphy from walking into your medical office is to have multiple and redundant checks and balances.

How do you do it?

Tuesday, September 08, 2009

Cost Containment: A Post Worth Revisiting



With declining reimbursements, the only way to to remain viable is through revenue generation coupled with cost containment. I'd like to talk a bit about costs, and some obvious--and not-so-obvious-ways to minimize them.
Fixed Costs: These are items like rent and insurance. While you probably have little negotiating power in this area, with regard to rent you can keep costs down the following ways:
Maximize productive use of space. I pay $26 per square foot, and use all of it productively. An EMR helps here, because I don't need to dedicate several hundred square feet to chart storage. Also, mobile units, such as portable sonogram machines, client computers, and portable lab equipment, also helps. And of course, I have VPN, because it essentially converts my house or Starbucks, or anywhere with an internet connection into an extension of the office.
Maximize revenue generation areas of the office. These areas include exam rooms, your office, and the lab. Back office functions, such as insurance claims submissions and billing work, can be virtual, via your VPN, yet remain "in-house" as opposed to being outsourced. With a well networked office, exam rooms can serve as exit offices while you go to the patient in the adjacent room.
On-demand Supply Ordering and Smart Storage: Closets = Square footage = $$. With some thought and planning, shelving, exam tables, cabinets, and closet space can be used for maximal storage at minimal square foot usage. In addition, I order supplies as needed, since my vendor, PSS Worldwide Medical, always delivers next day.
Variable costs: These include costs for items such as medical supplies, payroll, utilities, stamps, etc, and can be determined by examining the profit-loss statements prepared by the accountant. here are some ways to keep variable costs down.
On-demand supply ordering. DELL Computers uses this concept. I do as well, just make sure you don't run out of Foley drainage bags after you've already placed the Foley.
Part-time employees: Simple. They cost less than full time employees, plus no overtime.
On-demand staffing: I staff heaviest on the busiest days. Plus, since I am capable and willing to pick-up slack on days that we are inadvertently short staffed, this method works out well. Busy days or light days, open or closed, phones are always!!! staffed.
Amortization of utility payouts. Most utility companies will estimate a fixed monthly cost for you to pay based on a prior years consumption. I like it for cash-flow management.
Have your phones (VOIP), cellphones, & internet on fixed plans, so that costs do not soar with usage. Get the maximum minutes for cell phones, since the incremental costs of the plan are much less than overage payments. VOIP is cheap, plus never varies with usage. On the balance, I've been happy with it, yes, even for the "mission critical" functions.

Fax. Why snail mail when you can fax the referral letter. Not only is it faster, more efficient, and trackable, it is cheaper. I love my fax. Yeh, yeh, yeh, I know, HIPAA. But it can be done and still be in compliance
Direct costs: These are costs that are directly involved in patient care. Here's how to minimize these costs.
Everyone does everything. MA's do data entry, answer phones, clean rooms etc. The docs answer phones (if they are not seeing patients) when needed, clean rooms, order supplies, schedule patients, e-file labs. Again, an EMR and a VPN helps here as well.
Part time employees and on-demand staffing: see above.
Creative patient scheduling: Figure out which works best for you; clinic, open access, proportional, or wave scheduling, and then determine minimal staff requirements for your office hours.
Ergonomic room design. I have rigged my rooms so that I can do a many procedures without an assistant present. I learned these skills as a surgery resident in central line clinic. In fact, I can prep with my left hand, place the scope with my right hand, and simultameously do a UA with my toes (kidding!). If you have 2 hands, a brain, and a Mayo Stand, you can make it work as well, and in the mean time, you'll free up staff to answer phones and book new patients or enter claims.
Training and process management: Training employees well and developing efficient processes of doing business will allow you and your employees to work smarter and with less mistakes and to get the job done right the first time. This simply saves money. Also, keep your employees happy. Turnover is very expensive and disruptive.
Indirect costs: These costs cover non-patient care activities, such as back-office staff and billers. Here's how to minimize these costs.
See direct costs.
Remote working

EMR
Embrace technology
Multi-task
Training and process management

Consider outsourcing when appropriate.

Monday, August 31, 2009

What is your donut?

I was talking to my father-in-law the other day about a client of his who is a baker. This baker used to make lots of fancy and expensive items, such as cakes and tortes, but now he makes mostly donuts. He did not always do this. He began to do it out of neccessity. Donuts, you see, are high profit margin products.

Dunkin Donuts only makes donuts and coffee and guarentee them to be fresh anytime. Dunkin Donuts can do this because donuts are so cheap to make and they have such a high profit margin, that the store can afford to throw away items that have gone stale.

Urology has high profit margin procedures. Vasectomies and cystoscopies are 2 examples. Larger, maga-groups have radiation therapy for prostate cancer, which for now has a high margin. Laboratory work is low margin. Major surgery in the hospital is low margin.

In your practice, what has a high margin?

Wednesday, December 24, 2008

My New Years Business Resolution

Someone in the Enteprenwur Group ask the question about business plans for next year. Here is my answer.

  • reviewed and revised my business plan for 09.
  • upgraded to EMR-PM system
  • Hired coding consultant
  • Hired lab consultant
  • Plan to expand lab test menu
  • Improve marketing: email, direct mail, targeted mail, blogging, adwords, twitter
  • Increase referral base
  • Outsource collections for deadbeats
  • Improve collections: check scan, cc's, EMR-PM, cash
  • Answering phones 24/7
  • Making it easy for new patients to book and be seen
Anything else that I'm missing?

Dr S

Tuesday, April 15, 2008

A Guiding Vision


I'd never heard it described quite like that, but guiding vision perfectly describes the concept that I have been trying to convey in several The Independent Urologist posts of recent and past.

A guiding vision.

I like the sound of it. I like its imagery.

A guiding vision, as described to me today by a remarkable coach, Philippa Kennealy MD, represents your long range vision or ultimate goal. This vision guides you and helps you make decisions in the face of uncertainty. It can help you decide where to spend valuable resources or when to join a group or when to leave one.

I have understood the concept for the past 2 years--and it has served me well.
But the words, Guiding Vision; tremendous.

Thanks, Philippa.

The IU.


Powered by ScribeFire.

Tuesday, April 08, 2008

A reader question: How long to positive cash flow in start-up?

One of my readers (not my mom) asked me a question that deserves an answer. Hopefully, she will read this post.
The question was:

When does the
cash-flow usually come in after starting a practice?



Answer: Depends

Medical practice is a business and start-up is start-up. Most start-ups will fail in the first year for one simple reason; they run out of money before cash flow can cover expenses. When these businesses will run out of money depends on a variety of factors. The most important factors are access to capital, type of business, competition, and payer mix. Business that start-out with less than $5000 cash will usually fail in the first year, while those that have access to $100,000 or greater, will most likely live beyond their one year anniversary. If you want to survive, I recommend raising money, and lot's-o-it.

The type of practice you have makes a difference as well. Some practice's have inherently high start-up costs while others can be started with significantly less money. For example, I started my urology practice with $40,000 down and access to $150,000 in case the unowhat hit the fan. An internist may be able to start-up for even less, while an OB-Gyn in NY will need in excess of $200,000 to start-up. But the start-up costs only tell part of the story. A urologist may have high costs compared to an internist, but we also have higher revenue potential. A plastic surgeon or dermatologist in start-up can have very low up-front costs yet have a high earning potential and could thus become cash positive in a very short time. Contrast that to a primary care physician: they'll have relatively low initial costs but very little real income generation potential in today's climate. Plus, as they get busier, their costs escalate much faster than their revenue.

The third factor is competition. If you are the only urologist in town, you'll do well. If you are like me, one of 100s, you'll have to struggle a bit more to make money. A plastic surgeon in start-up on Long Island may have lower costs than, say, I did, but he/she has much fiercer competition than I faced. As for primary care; out here they are dime-a-dozen.

The fourth factor is payer mix. If your patients are insured, and you have enough of them, you'll start to make money. If you practice in a very well-off area and can go "out of network" you'll make the same money with less work and in less time. If you deal with predominantly Medicaid, you'll probably have to move because you'll never get there.

As for me,
my cash flow turned positive after 9 months of hemorrhage.

I started in April 06 with a $40,000 initial investment and was prepared to pour another $150,000 of my own money into the practice to "float it" in a worse case scenario. Initially I estimated a loss of $30-50K in year one and a break even point by end of year 2. I felt that by end of year three I'd start to make in excess of $100K per year. In actuality, I broke even by end of year one and made a modest, yet respectable, profit by end of year 2. This year I have been doing quite well. While I had to dip into my savings, I repaid those loans quickly.

Caveat:

While I have already recovered my initial investment and have been making some money, I am still greater than $200,000 in the hole if you factor in loss of income during my first 2+ years of start-up compared to what I'd have earned had I stayed an employee. So be forewarned: the freedom to be your own boss comes at great cost.

So good luck Rose and please feel free to contact me.

The IU.

Thursday, December 06, 2007

Damn December

December! Everyone loves it, right. The holidays, parties, joy, peace and love on earth.

Bahumbug!!

The holiday season can be a difficult time for many people. The depressed or lonely are the obvious people that come to mind. But I'm talking about the small business owners. Whether you are in retail, food service, or health care, the holiday season brings many challenges to your business. In retail, for example, experts project poor sales for this year, and owners, managers, and employees of retail chains and mom & pop stores alike may suffer the consequences.

Medicine, contrary to what I was told as a pre-med student, is far from recession proof. In medicine, we suffer right along with everyone else, minus the insurance execs.

I am not going to get into the economics of whether or not we are in a recession. We are, however, in a period of difficult economic times for many people. This economic downturn, in addition to consumer pressures that the holidays bring, mean less money spent on health care. i.e., we, the doctors, suffer.

Let's take the example of a typical patient of mine, a 35 year old man who wants a vasectomy. He works for someone else, most likely a big, faceless corporation or government agency, and his employer pays for his health insurance. His family income is $150,000 per year, which does not go very far in the New York metro area. Like everyone else, his co-pays or deductibles have risen dramatically in recent years. Far from being 5 dollars, now they are in the $35 to $50 range. His children, like my own, have had one cold after the next, after the next, and he has paid several hundred dollars in co-pays for his kids' pediatrician visits. His oldest daughter wants a new dance leotard and a Webkins doll for Christmas and his younger girl wants a Fiona doll and a Bella Dancerella video. Perhaps he and his wife agreed to not spend money on each other, but knowing that this really means "get me something," he buys his wife some inexpensive jewelry and plans to take her out for sushi. On top of all that, the pre-school/day care tuition for his toddler is due by Jan 1, or else, and that ain't cheap.

So how does this affect me? Well, he and his wife have decided that 2 children are enough and that he should have a vasectomy. Most likely, his insurance will cover it. But he still has co-pays. And I don't waive those. I simply cannot do that. Since he has all these other bills to pay, does not relish the idea of paying the 2 or more co-pays required for the vasectomy. In addition, he can't afford to take any time what-so-ever off from work, even though vasectomy patients recover quickly. He thus decides hold off for now on his vasectomy.

Multiply this times 20 vasectomies per month, times God know's how many other elective things that I do in urology, and you can see why December can be a difficult month for a urologist or any other doctor.

But Happy Holidays.

The IU.

Monday, November 26, 2007

Cost Consciousness and Medical Practice

An interesting article in the NYTimes on air travel reminded me of what has become of the experience of seeing a doctor. Basically, the article talked about levels of service on airlines and who gets what type of service and why. In the airline business, the overwhelming majority of travelers chose carriers based solely on cost. I include myself in this category. As a result, we have become loyal to the price of the seat, rather than to the airline itself. The airlines know that our loyalty and our business come only with low fares, and that our business will leave with higher fares, and they have determined that keeping us happy is no longer important. Now, the airlines can cut out perks that once made flying enjoyable, or at least tolerable. The fact that we complain privately and publicly is not important, since they can always get our business back by running a special deal. On the otherhand, people who are willing to pay for business or first class get treated like royalty. Wine, no lines, chateau-braind. Very nice. While both coach and first class passengers arrive at the destination at the same time, the high paying customers have a better experience.



Like the airline industry, people that can afford better care, either on their own or via the best of the best insurance plans, get better treatment. They can be seen without referrals, go to out-of network providers, and get any medication the doctor prescribes. They can even go to a concierge model physician practice. This is like flying business or first class. For the rest of us, we have to fly coach.

The costs associated with running an airline have risen dramatically over the years. So has the cost of administering health care or purchasing health insurance. In the airline industry, at one end of the spectrum low cost carriers exist that cater only to the cost conscious traveler. At the opposite end of the spectrum is the corporate jet industry that caters to the high end, low volume traveler that cares solely about convenience and comfort. In the middle, we have the typical airline company, like United Airlines or American, that have first and business class for the "out-of-network" travel and coach for the rest of us in-network only customers.

Comparing the airline industry to the medical profession is easy. Flying low cost only carriers is like going to a clinic. You'll get to your location, or get your care, but it won't be pleasant. Flying business class or first class is like going to a concierge medical office or a medi-spa. Not only will you get to the location, you'll have a great experience on the way. Flying coach on a major carrier is like going to the typical doctor. It used to be nothing fancy, nothing great, but pleasant enough. Now it is horrible. As the airlines get squeezed, and as the doctors get squeezed, and as we the consumers let everyone know that we care only about cost, the experience is becoming less and less tolerable.

I don't have a solution for any of this. It is just my observation. I suppose that if you want premium medical care, like air travel, you will have to pay for it yourself. Otherwise you can join the rest of us in the coach section of modern medicine.

Friday, September 21, 2007

The Free Market and Medicine

I often overhear in the physician lounges, or read on the internet, about many doctors' views on the free market. Typically, the doctors argue that "standard free market principles" do not apply to medical practice. Their arguments go something like this:
  • I charge $180 for an new patient consult, but only get paid $90, and therefore, free market principles do not apply.
  • I charge $5000 for a total knee, but only get $1200, and therefore, free market principles do not apply.
  • A radical prostatectomy is worth $4000, yet I only get $900 and therefore, free market principles do not apply.

Over the past 7 years, I have heard this line of reasoning hundreds of times.

I don't think they understand the free market. Let's use another industry to elucidate and clarify the problem. Let's use the toy industry.

Mattel designs, markets, and sells toys, but they don't make them. Since Mattel is a corporation, it's fiduciary responsibility is to maximize profits. One way to do this is by minimizing costs. A great way to minimize production costs is to outsource manufacturing to countries that can do it more cheaply. Mattel outsources toy manufacturing to Chinese factories.

Mattel, like United Health Care, has lots of money and thus leverage over the manufacturers. Mattel uses this leverage to negotiate production costs for its toys. The Chinese factories can either take it or leave it. Since the factories can not remain viable without a contract from Mattel, they choose to accept the terms of the contract, and then attempt to maximize their own profits by cutting production costs and increasing production rates. The Chinese factory does this by paying workers extremely low wages, using cheap materials, and, as we have now learned, using inexpensive lead based paints on the toys.

Mattel pays the factories cut-throat rates, which forces the factories to cut corners to make a profit, which, unfortunately, can ultimately impact the consumer negatively. On the other hand, however, the consumers in the USA and Europe, don't want to pay a lot for their toys, so the cycle continues.

Sounds familiar, right.

United Health Care does not produce health care, it only pays for it. As a corporation, its fiduciary responsibility is to maximize profits. One way it can do this is by minimizing production costs. United Health uses it's leverage, much like Mattel and the Chinese factories, to negotiate cut-throat production rates to the factories, which in this case are the providers. Unable to remain viable without the contract, we chose to take it, rather than leave it.

Now, to maximize our own profits, we attempt to cut our costs and increase production. We do this by outsourcing services, downsizing office (factory) sizes, and hiring low wage personnel and then we see more and more patients. The downside of this is that ultimately the consumer--the patient--can get hurt because in our efforts to cut-corners and increase production, we may make mistakes and hurt people. As a society, we accept this because, like toy purchasers, consumers of health care don't want to pay a lot for the product and the cycle continues.

See, our health care model is the epitome of the free market, and anyone who suggests otherwise is wrong.

Thanks for listening,

The IU.